Our Editions:
News

Trump, Xi and Putin Summit in Shenzhen: Why Europe Is Talking About “Yalta 2.0”

Ahead of Thursday’s one-hour meeting on the sidelines of APEC, comparisons with the 1945 conference are filling European headlines.

Trump, Xi and Putin Summit in Shenzhen: Why Europe Is Talking About “Yalta 2.0” - SurgeZirc FR
Trump, Xi and Putin.Getty Images

A single word has been echoing around Europe for weeks: Yalta. As Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin prepare to sit down together in Shenzhen on Thursday 19 November, the murmur has grown into a chorus.

The three presidents will meet on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum. The talks are expected to be brief: Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said on Wednesday that they would last “no more than an hour”. Even so, the international press has covered the summit extensively, and many outlets have drawn parallels with the Yalta conference.

That conference took place in the Crimean seaside resort in February 1945. Britain’s Winston Churchill, America’s Franklin D. Roosevelt and the Soviet Union’s Joseph Stalin met to discuss the end of the Second World War, only months before Nazi Germany surrendered.

It left a lasting mark on Europe, and with it the memory, more mythical than scientific, of a gathering where the continent’s future was settled without its involvement. The “spheres of influence” associated with it became the Western and Eastern blocs of the Cold War.

Why Is Europe Invoking Yalta During the Ukraine War?

With the war in Ukraine continuing, the idea of Russian, Chinese and American leaders discussing the future of a weakened Europe has led some to reach for the Yalta comparison. It surfaced at the end of October on France Inter and Euronews, and appeared again this Wednesday in Ouest-France and L’Opinion. Google search trends for the word “Yalta” over the past month show a sudden spike in interest.

Bertrand Badie, professor emeritus at Sciences Po Paris, offered several explanations to Le HuffPost for the hype around a supposed “Yalta 2.0”. He said the comparison rests on “serious errors” in historical and geopolitical terms. It stems above all, he said, from the “old human reflex” of “starting from the known” to “try to shed light on the unknown”. In this case, the unknown is a meeting between China, Russia and the United States “that is not part of the norm of post-1945 world diplomacy”.

Zelensky has also addressed the subject. The Ukrainian president said he “really” did not want the meeting to “turn into Yalta 2, 3, 4, with a redistribution of spheres of influence”.

“P5 Minus Two”: Europe’s Absence From the Shenzhen Talks

Another phrase has been circulating: “P5 minus two”. The summit brings together three of the five permanent members of the UN Security Council, without France and the United Kingdom.

A Guardian columnist wrote that the success of the Shenzhen-Yalta analogy, despite its weakness, “is above all indicative of the anxiety” of Europeans who “will not be present”. Germany’s Der Spiegel feared that Europe would become “a pawn in the hands of a triumvirate”.

Badie agreed that the label carries weight. “This ‘P5 minus two’ is still quite spectacular,” he said, adding that the fascination with the meeting is also explained by the fact that “it fuels the idea of an excluded Europe”. He cautioned, however, that the debate over the summit should not obscure the responsibility of Europeans in their own situation. “They are worried and humiliated by being excluded, but they can’t seem to grasp their relationship with the rest of the world,” he said, or see themselves as “a power distinct from American power”.

Why Experts Say the Yalta Comparison Does Not Hold

Badie insisted that “the current context has absolutely nothing to do with that of 1945”. “It’s actually the opposite,” he said. He recalled that the wartime Allies embodied power “at its peak” as well as being “virtuous”, as they were on the verge of “defeating the Nazi monster”.

By comparison, he observed, the powers negotiating in Shenzhen seem more “challenged and defeated”. He pointed to Ukrainian resistance against Putin, and to the “Hormuz trap” that closed on Trump, whom he described as a “lame duck” since the midterm elections. He also cited the failure of Trump’s trade war. “Power is being defeated everywhere,” Badie said, whether militarily or economically.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: Laurent Nuñez Faces Court Complaint Over Police Injury Figures During French Protests

The Wall Street Journal reported that setbacks suffered by Moscow and Washington are prompting Beijing to be cautious about any military adventure, and noted that China faces a sluggish economy. Badie summed up the idea that the leaders in Shenzhen could rule the world through their conversations as “utterly absurd”.

Historian Antoine Arjakovsky holds a similar view. Writing in Le Monde, he described the Yalta analogy as “as false as it is dangerous”. In his view, it “offers” the Chinese, American and Russian presidents a “narrative of power” that they “did not obtain on the ground”, and could even “produce its own reality”. He argued this might lead the guests in Shenzhen to consider themselves more powerful than they are.

How Russian Media Has Covered the Trump-Xi-Putin Summit

In Russia, the meeting has been presented as a source of pride. Although Peskov dismissed the comparison with Yalta, it was widely reported in the Russian press.

Courrier International, reviewing the headlines, quoted sinologist Alexei Chigadayev, who said the announcement of the Shenzhen meeting was the subject of a “concerted media campaign” in Russia. Russian outlets highlighted Putin’s meeting with his counterparts, even though no clear agenda had been set and the talks might not lead to anything.

Badie argued that drawing uncritical parallels with Yalta is problematic at a time when the Kremlin wants to “resurrect the spirit of the Cold War” and the MAGA sphere dreams of a return to American “greatness” and power. “We’re playing into all these narratives,” he said.

Want to join the conversation?

Checking sign-in…